The 1991 conference, mainly on universalism and the doctrine of hell, led to these papers. Let me now sketch what i take to be a strong doctrine of universalism. Apr 22, 2009 is the doctrine of hell a hindrance or a help in witnessing. In the contemporary interpretation of scriptural teaching on hell, as on other doctrines, we look to the holy spirit to illuminate us and lead us into the truth. Contemporary reflections on the doctrine of hell in the teaching of jonathan edwards, the evangelical quarterly 67. The christian debate does not concern whether hell will be a blogger denny burke thinks that bells weak view of hell if based on reality all agree that it will but, rather, what the nature of that a weak view of sin which, in turn, is based on a weak view of god. Hell thereby becomes a means of grace where gods love eventually.
Universalism and the doctrine of hell the gospel coalition. Although the most important reason for rejecting eternal torture is the simple fact that the bible does not teach it, there are other strong arguments in opposition to it, not the least being that it is utterly repulsive to the instinctive moral and judicial senses of. The prevailing doctrine of the christian church during its first five hundred years damned nonsense. The liberal doctrine of hell and universalism university of divinity.
God, it is inconceivable that anyone will ever end up in hell forever. Fanning, don, the doctrine of hell and missions 2009. Universalism and the doctrine of hell scottish bulletin of evangelical. But universal salvation is the reality which god wills and which therefore must come about. Committee to determine whether the preaching of universalism i. Though both are the truth, one universal restoration is the truth as it is for god and as it is for faith the further side of decision. God does indeed hate sin and does indeed judge sinners. Jesus warned his hearers of the eternal punishment awaiting those who reject him matt. Universalism is the religious doctrine that every created person will sooner or later be reconciled to god, the loving source of all that is, and will in the process be reconciled to all other persons as well. Jun 25, 2019 universalism pronounced yuniversulizum is a doctrine that teaches all people will be saved. Insofar as christianity is a historical religion and includes substantive beliefs about the death and resurrection of jesus christ, christians are indeed committed to the view that. Hell may hold carnival on earth to the glory of the god of heaven. The conference is increasingly turning to subjects which require some courage in the handling.
Universalism and the problem of hell patsalidou 2012. The doctrine of hell has sparked considerable debate, especially since. In the matter of universalism, the question is how a good god could send people to hell a place of conscious tormentforever. As ronald blue points out, this debate touches on several major doctrines of christianity. The metaphorical view of hell reasons that hell s torment is only symbolic. In this essay we explain why the doctrine of hell poses a problem of evil for traditional theists in. Historically, all species of christian universalism prior to the twentieth century affirmed a doctrine of hell and most versions of christian universalism still do. Literal, metaphorical, purgatorial and conditional edited by william crockett most contemporary christians acknowledge the doctrine of hell, but theyd rather not think about how god punishes the wicked. One of the main reasons the doctrine of universalism is spreading so rapidly across parts of christianity is due to the fact that many people simply cannot believe that a good and loving god could literally throw people down into a hell for all of eternity. Dec 29, 2017 it is in rejecting this love that one can experience a hell of ones own creation. Universalism and the doctrine of hell scottish bulletin of evangelical theology special study cameron, nigel s. Chapter 18 jesus christ did not teach or believe in hell chapter 19 the rich man and lazarus chapter 20 the absurdities of the doctrine of hell. Torrance on election, freedom, universalism and hell. Universalism and the doctrine of hell scottish bulletin of.
The purgatorial view of hell offers sinners an escape. Although the most important reason for rejecting eternal torture is the simple fact that the bible does not teach it, there are other strong arguments in opposition to it, not the least being that it is utterly repulsive to the instinctive moral and judicial senses of anyone with a conscience. Christian universalism and the belief or hope in the universal reconciliation through christ can even be understood as synonyms. Universalism and the problem of hell wiley online library. Two church theories have been advanced in opposition to the doctrine of eternal punishment.
The thought of people burning in hell for eternity is most repugnant to the human mind. Bauckhams article is a historical argument against universalism. The biblical doctrine of hell examined brian schwertley the doctrine of eternal punishment is probably the most unpopular, hated and feared teaching in the entire bible. For general background on the term and its history. Drawing not only from scripture, the early church fathers, and the puritans, but also from secular philosophy and history, the book aims not to defend the doctrine of hell, but attempts something bolderto persuade that hell, in all its terror, is good. The problem of hell is arguably the most severe form of the problem of evil because the evil found in hell is eternal with no possibility for redemption.
The salvation of all was taught by jesus, the apostles john and paul, then later by the evangelist marcion, 120 140 ad, theopholus. So, like incarcerated people at the end of their sentences, people in hell may eventually be freed from their sufferings. The doctrine of hell and eternal conscious punishment. Wide is the road that leads to life universalism may be defined as the teaching that though hell may exist it will. The doctrine has often been rejected by mainstream christian religion, which holds to the doctrine of special salvation that only some members of humanity will eventually enter heaven, but it has received support from many prestigious christian thinkers as well as many groups of christians. Some of origens stronger statements of universalism were not extant in rufinuss text. Louis berkhof stated in his day, in present day theology there is an evident tendency in some circles to rule out the idea of eternal punishment. In reflecting on the doctrine of hell, we look for practical application to the churchs urgent task of mission and evangelism. It only stands to reason that their hell could not successfully coexist with universalism, so they also declared universalism to be heretical. Dec 21, 2020 explores our natural discomfort with hell, and then turns to argue for its goodness and glory. Wright on biblical universalism unsettled christianity. Hanson, universalism, the prevailing doctrine of the christian church during its first five hundred years boston and chicago.
Be the first to ask a question about universalism and the doctrine of hell lists with this book. The authors of four views on hell meet this subject headon with different views on what the scriptures say. Attempts to defend the traditional conception of hell usually come in one. Christian universalism is a school of christian theology focused around the doctrine of universal reconciliation the view that all human beings will ultimately be saved and restored to a right relationship with god. Nonchristians who deny eternal punishment might believe in reincarnation. But, for many, universalism is the view that rings most true, and the version of christianity theyd be most likely to accept. Universalism embraces the idea that god is too good to condemn hu mankind to eternal hell and that, sooner or later, all humanity will be saved. Packer states, the sentimental secularism of modern western culture, with its.
Universalists, in particular, try to evade the problem by claiming that a doctrine of hell is not in fact taught in the scriptures at least in its traditional form, and that christians are. Christianity, universalism, hell, free will, salvation, jesus christ, death, resurrection, freedom, christian doctrines thomas talbott thomas talbott is professor emeritus of philosophy at willamette university in salem, oregon, and has defended a doctrine of universal reconciliation in both theological and philosophical contexts. Universalis t publishing house, 1899 is still useful. Recondliationism a forgotten evangelical doctrine of hell. Hosea ballous ancient history of universalism, boston, 1828, 1842, 1872. Eternal punishment, the historic view of the church, holds that hell is a place of eternal, conscious, and final punishment, banishment, and death. Biblical scholars are exposing the teaching of hell for what it is and always has been, a tradition of man which has made the word of god of no effect. Even when a man has made his bed in hell gods hand of love will continue to grasp him there. Oepkeapokathistemi, apokata, stasis in theological dictionary of the new testament 1. Rather than being a defense for the doctrine of hell. The rise of modern universalism, southern baptist journal of theology 2. To examine universal salvation during the first 500 years of christianity, the works of three scholars are indisputably the finest. I was utterly amazed when i was clearly shown by the holy spirit that these were. How could a good god permit sin with all its destructive force.
Paternoster press contains a collection of papers from. The doctrine of hell puts a blocker on that push, but in so doing it generates a buildup of unresolved theological pressure that sometimes needs to be released. Dec 15, 2008 universalism can contribute to people procrastinating regarding salvation in the here and now in order to wait until the afterlife where they have a second chance, an opportunity to be purified in a hell like state after which they will then be able to go to heaven and be with god forever. Also see the list of new articles and books on tentmaker. Hell and the doctrine of universalism, and pursued dialogue with leading theologians of each view. The neardeath experience and christian universalism. The righteous purpose of gods judgment pdf document.
Annihilationists believe that, upon their release from hell, the souls of the damned are extinguished into nothingness. The doctrine of universalism involves more than a mere difference of opinion concerning eschatology. Understanding the early church doctrine of apokatastasis. An argument for universalism consisting of a critique of all of the alternatives to it pdf document hope beyond hell. Universalism and the reality of eternal punishment. The doctrine has often been rejected by mainstream christian religion, which holds to the doctrine of special salvation.
Christian universalism is growing around the world. Wide is the road that leads to life universalism may be defined as the teaching that though hell may exist it will eventually empty as gods will to save all persons individually will finally triumph. Universalism was a wellestablished doctrine in the early church. Nde, the doctrine of universal salvation, also known as univer salism, is the most compatible with contemporary nde accounts. Since the doctrine of hell is asserted by many christians to be not merely logically. Cameron, 1992, paternoster press, baker book house edition, in english. Universalism and the doctrine of hell, nigel cameron is. My thesis focuses on universalists and, in particular, on three contemporary christian. Universalism and the doctrine of hell 1992 edition open. The false doctrine of universalism bible knowledge. Universalism and the bible by professor keith derose from yale university. Both the participants and other contributors demonstrated genuine interest, courtesy and. Christian universalism and the belief or hope in the universal reconciliation through christ can even be understood as synonyms the term christian universalism was used in.
Its perhaps worth mentioning that christian universalism as a doctrine has existed since patristic times first 300 years after christ and it has been argued though personally i think questionably that it was the prevailing doctrine in the first 500 years until quashed by the doctrine of eternal constant torment hell for the lost, that. Download a pdf file of this issue for free download christian. May 19, 2014 jerome was a harsh critic of origen and of rufinuss latin translation, and historians, assuming that the church had specifically condemned origen, trusted jerome rather than rufinus. Thus, the doctrine of hell gives rise to a specific moral problem caused by the apparent incompatibility between gods goodness and love and everlasting torment in hell. Part iii additional important information for understanding gods plan for all chapter 21 calvinism, arminianism and universalism. Probably to a conception of hell a lot less clearcut than i might have imagined, stretched somewhere between the jerusalem municipal rubbish dump and a shadowy underworld borrowed from greek mythology.
Universalism and the doctrine of hell scottish bulletin of evangelical theology special study. Although universalism has appeared at various times in christian history, most notably in the works of origen of alexandria in the 3rd century, as an organized movement it had its beginnings in the united states in the middle of the 18th century. How universalism, the opiate of the theologians, went. It is to the credit of the conference that it gave opportunity for evangelicals unhappy with a doctrine of endless suffering an opportunity to state their case. Probably to a conception of hell a lot less clearcut than i might have imagined, stretched somewhere between the jerusalem municipal rubbish dump and a shadowy underworld borrowed from. In a 1986 book on paradise and the fire, sulayman al. Many of the passages that are typically utilized to attack universalism teach exclusivism which here refers to the doctrine that its only exclusively through the saving work of christ that any can be saved. A few noted evangelicals such as clark pinnock,1 john stott,2 and john wenham3 have in recent years challenged the doctrine of eternal torment forever in hell as gods final judgment on all unbelievers. Some universalists believe that after a certain cleansing period, god will free the inhabitants of hell and reconcile them to himself. Hosea ballou iis ancient history of universalism 1842, edward beechers history of opinions on the scriptural doctrine of retribution 1878, and john wesley hansons universalism, the prevailing doctrine.
For if universalism is the opiate of the theologians, then all eschatology is the opiate of the faithful, as is too the doctrine of the fall its protological corollary which invites us to see our world as but a shadow of gods original creative design. I agree that exclusivism is clearly taught in the new testament, so i wont bother to cite the supporting passages. Thirdly, the doctrine of hell is closely connected with other doctrines of christianity, especially the doctrine of atonement and many christian conservatives held. This will assist us in understanding the increasing popularity of universalism and moreover, on what grounds it is challenged. Article in journal or book, howard davies, judgement. Colwell, the glory of gods justice and the glory of gods grace. Papers presented at the fourth edinburgh conference in christian dogmatics, 1991 cameron, nigel m. Universalism the belief that all mankind will, in the end, be saved, regardless of their lives. A biblical and theological critique rick wade introduction 1. Theologian albert mohler says the basic issue for universalism is theodicy. It would be easy to hold together the awful reality of hell and the universal reign of god if hell means destruction and the impenitent are no more. The theory of universalism eliminates hell altogether. If election is true, what is the danger in universalism. In christian theology, universal reconciliation also called universal salvation, christian universalism, or in context simply universalism is the doctrine that all sinful and alienated human soulsbecause of divine love and mercywill ultimately be reconciled to god.
Aquinas in the thirteenth, taught that the sufferings of t. Many evangelicals are ashamed of this biblical doctrine, viewing it as a blemish to be covered up by the cosmetic of divine love. Universalism and the doctrine of hell scottish bulletin. One of the ways that it can be released is by pushing out eternalist interpretations of hell like a cork from champagne and embracing universalism. This is a doctrine which says that all without exception will be redeemed dixon 26. Universalism, belief in the salvation of all souls. Other scholarly resources on the subjects of the victorious gospel of jesus christ and his victory over hell. Conditional immortality, in universalism and the doctrine of hell, pp. Universalist reading list roger tutt aka ted jones lists the books on universalism that helped him out of his depression caused by the death of his son salvation of all mankind. Oct 12, 2012 the paper begins with an explanation of the doctrine of hell and an identification of the main problems and criticisms against it. A legacy of fear and persecution chapter 3 pdf saint pauls universalism chapter 5 pdf god, freedom and human destiny chapter 11 pdf. At that time, i was doing an in depth word study in the hebrew and greek scriptures on the subjects of hell and the lake of fire. In christian theology, universal reconciliation is the doctrine that all sinful and alienated human soulsbecause of divine love and mercywill ultimately be reconciled to god. Others view hell as a temporary place or state which oburns off o the unclean sinfulness of the damned.
Universalism, also known as the doctrine of apokatostasis restoration, emphasizes that one day the bad dream of sin will be over and we shall all rise and go back to our father and home dixon 26. The purpose of this book is to present some of the evidence of the prevalence in the early centuries of the christian church, of the doctrine of the final holiness of all. Nov 16, 2020 universalism and the doctrine of hell by nigel m. The eastern church held a stronger view in favor of universalism than did the church at rome. Other names for this doctrine are universal restoration, universal reconciliation, universal restitution, and universal salvation. The paper begins with an explanation of the doctrine of hell and an identification of the main problems and criticisms against it. These texts do not lead me to universalism, because of the many others which speak of the terrible and eternal reality of hell. It is a doctrine which the natural heart revolts from and struggles against. This electronic thesis or dissertation has been downloaded from. The conditional view of hell declares god to be too merciful to inflict eternal punishment. Hell is a reality in the existential situation of the man facing the challenge of the gospel.
This important fact in the history of christian eschatology was first brought out prominently in a volume, very valuable, and for its time very thorough. The main argument for universalism is that a good and loving god would not condemn people to eternal torment in hell. Papers presented at the fourth edinburgh conference in christian dogmatics, 1991. Chapter 21 calvinism, arminianism and universalism gods. Rejecting the doctrine of hell in favour on universal salvation. Now, one doesnt have to accept universalism to avoid the doctrine of eternal hell one can accept some view on which those who dont make it to heaven are eventually or right away annihilated.
903 576 272 1540 1222 1742 445 963 1725 214 1694 1242 1507 1445 377 61 1679 94 1554 220 1644 1511 940 97 772 514 82 280 833 283 710